I’ve been hosting White Elephant gift exchanges for years, and I’ve seen it all: the gifts that got passed around like hot cocoa, the ones that no one wanted to open, and those rare gems that sparked all-out gift-stealing battles. That’s why I’ve created this guide—a roundup of White Elephant gift exchange ideas that includes the best, funniest, and most popular gifts under $25. And the best part? I update this list every year with fresh favorites that are guaranteed to spark laughs, surprises, and maybe even a little friendly competition.
From laugh-out-loud gag gifts to surprisingly useful finds, these are the gifts everyone hopes to take home. Ready to be the hit of your White Elephant exchange? Grab your wrapping paper—and if you need a refresher on the rules or how to host the perfect party, check out my White Elephant Party Guide for all the tips!
Heads up: Some of the links below are affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you) if you decide to make a purchase. I only shared gifts that have been big hits at our White Elephant parties (and yes, I’ve seen them get stolen multiple times).
Best White Elephant Gift Exchange Ideas
These are the gifts that always get stolen in round after round. These are the best White Elephant gift exchange gifts: fun, practical, and just clever enough to be irresistible.
From Crook to Cook: Snoop Dog Cook Book
There is something funny about Snoop Dog having a cookbook. This was an immediate hot item that got a lot of laughs and steals.
Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker
I don’t know why this was such a big hit. Maybe because it’s so weirdly awesome, but the fact is, this was one of the most stolen and talked about gifts. It also comes in a single.
I think the nostalgia this lamp evoked is what made it such a big hit. Whatever the reason was, this was stolen until it couldn’t be stolen anymore.
After reflection of this list, I realize that basically anything Snoop was a big hit. The reason is probably because we’re all Gen-X and Millennials.
Snoop on the Stoop Christmas Elf
A Snoop Dog Christmas Elf? Immediately Yes! Imagine an elf on the shelf, but with a little something extra. This was a huge hit.
Funny Ideas for White Elephant Gift Exchange
These funny ideas for White Elephant Gift Exchange are sure to make people howl with laughter, then spark a battle for who will get to take it home.
Poo-Pourri Before You Go Toilet Spray 5 Pack
Poo-Pourri spray is guaranteed to get a good round of laughs. It’s practical and hilarious, and I think that is what makes it such a good White Elephant gift.
Squatty Potty The Original Bathroom Toilet Stool
The Squatty Potty is such a good pick that one year, two were entered in the game, and both were stolen numerous times.
Big Cock Ranch Gourmet Seasoning Bundle
The name alone of this pack of seasonings had people cracking up. BUT word after the party was that they were actually really tasty.
Martha and Snoop Celebrity Glass Jar Candle
This Martha and Snoop prayer candle duo is sure to get laughs and be in high demand. Hilarious and useful because we always need candles.
White Elephant Gifts Under $25 (Steal-Worthy on a Budget)
These are the White Elephant gift exchange ideas that have all the charm with none of the overspending. If you budget is $25 or less, these gifts are a perfect choice.
I Pee In Pools Retro Style Trucker Hat
This hat was hilarious when it was opened, so many laughs, and it was stolen until it was locked, yet it is still under $25.
It was an immediate lol moment when this was opened. This was stolen the max number of times (I still have regret I didn’t end up with it). The gifter loaded it up with scratchers as well, so it made the gift that much more appealing.
This one is for the feral ACOTAR girlies (and dudes). Anyone would fight over the chance to read by candlelight with the scent of their favorite book boyfriend.
I love how this list includes both funny and practical gifts, making it easy to find something that will actually be enjoyed at a white elephant exchange. Some ideas feel really unique!
All these have been big hits for us at our White Elephant party! I can’t wait to see what gems are uncovered at this year’s exchange.